Franchise Defenseman: Dion Phaneuf (Calgary Flames)

If ever the distinction between “best” and “prototypical” is needed, it’s here. Phaneuf isn’t the best defenseman in the league – that’s an honor that clearly goes to Nicklas Lidstrom. But a big body who’s not afraid of making contact, is one of the best hitters in the league, has a bomb of a shot from the point and plays top-tier defense is what most hockey fans think of when they think of number one defenseman.

Other considered: Nicklas Lidstrom, Chris Pronger, Scott Niedermayer, Jay Bouwmeester

Number Two Defenseman: Chris Phillips (Ottawa Senators)

Like second line forwards there’s not a lot that is set in stone when it comes to discussing number two defensemen, a role that can be filled by a good all-around around player who doesn’t quite have enough skill to be a number one, a stay-at-home defenseman who moves the puck well, or a powerplay quarterback. Since I’m doing this by pairing I thus turned my focus to blueliners who could play a defensive role well enough to let their partner get in to the offensive player, but who have enough offensive talent to contribute on occasion. Phillips is such a player, fast enough to match up with the league’s better forwards, a solid hitter and an excellent shot blocker who also has enough offensive awareness to chip in. Though not a great playmaker, Phillips does have a hard shot and, just as importantly, a very good sense of when to jump into the play.

Others considered: Braydon Coburn, Brendan Witt